Mar 12 2010

Dealing with the Humaniacs

Many thanks to the fine dairymen and women who invited HumaneWatch's David Martosko to speak to them on Thursday in Modesto, California. These people are the bend-but-don't-break strength of America, the unsung heroes of our blissfully ignorant supermarket experience. We were honored to spend yesterday with them at their annual convention.

What we didn't know, however, was that a reporter from The Modesto Bee was also spending his day in the convention hall. In retrospect, we're really glad he could make it for my presentation, which was titled "How to Deal with the 'Humaniacs' in Ten Easy Lessons."

We've already gotten a few e-mails from readers who saw the resulting news story when it hit the Bee's website. They tell us (1) that seeing such awesome press coverage is the next best thing to being there; (2) that HSUS has seldom sounded so defensive; and (3) that there just might be hope for American agriculture yet.

It's always nice to hear optimism, even if we're just "hearing" it in an e-mail.

The article even includes a cameo from "Dairy Goddess" blogger Barbara Martin (who was a great lunch companion). Here's a taste:

The Humane Society of the United States masquerades as a protector of pets while plotting the demise of the dairy industry, a critic of the group said Thursday.

David Martosko, speaking in Modesto at the annual meeting of Western United Dairymen, said the society is attacking milk producers as part of its effort to turn Americans into vegans.

"They are not promoting kinder treatment of farm animals," said Martosko, director of research for the Center for Consumer Freedom in Washington, D.C. "They are promoting the abolition of farm animals."

Martosko said many people believe that the society mainly funds dog and cat shelters when in fact it spends most of its hefty income on lobbying, salaries and political donations ...

Martosko said activists with the society, whom he dubbed "humaniacs," believe that animals have rights and should not be eaten, hunted or used in laboratories.

"The humaniacs are people who make it their life's mission to use the concept of humane treatment of animals in order to hobble you, to drive you out of business," he said.

Click here to read the whole story, feel free to leave a comment, and please pass this along to your friends and neighbors.

Related People

Related Organizations

Posted on 03/12/2010 at 03:28 AM by the HumaneWatch Team

Dairy • (7) Comments

Share

Comments 

The Humane Society wants The Humane Slaughter Act enforced.

The Humane Society wants dairy cows free from abuse and neglect.

The Humane Society wants veal calves to be unconscoius when they are being sliced up.

And for that they are being attacked.

Posted by Pam on 03/12 at 06:44 AM

Pam, you’re suggesting that HSUS only wants those things. Which is not the case. If it were, I don’t think anyone would have a problem with HSUS.

Every farmer I met this week in California also wants the Humane Slaughter Act enforced. They all want dairy cows to be free from abuse and neglect. And absolutely none of them is A-OK with butchering conscious animals. Not one.

I think the general objection here is that while HSUS says they want these unobjectionable things in order to gain popular support, their real aims are quite different.

Ask yourself this: If all HSUS’s leaders want is for Americans to have access to meat, dairy, and eggs that were produced without abusing animals, and if they’re really excited about some livestock producers’ transitions to so-called “cruelty-free” production methods (cage-free eggs, free-range chicken, etc.)—how come they still won’t eat any of it themselves?

It’s my contention that Wayne Pacelle, Paul Shapiro, Josh Balk, et al (at HSUS) don’t believe that such a thing as “humane” or “cruelty-free” meat or milk exists. I think they’re dead wrong, but I believe that’s their honest opinion.

if I’m wrong, so be it. Mr. Pacelle can prove it to me. All he has to do is sit down to dinner with me. We’ll serve the most humanely raised veal, cheese, omelets, and pork chops on the planet. I’ll buy the meal, and we’ll spare no expense. Nobody else in the room but me, him, and 10 photographers.

I don’t think he’ll show.

Do you?

Posted by HumaneWatch on 03/12 at 03:43 PM

I read the story about your speech in Modesto. You are correct. The dairy industry does have something to fear about being targeted by the U.S. Humane Society. Just look at the 2008 election and the targeting of egg farmers. And, it worked! Why? Because “city folks” have become so removed from their food supply that they will believe anything. Happy chickens? Happy cows?

No doubt dairy farmers’ reflex response is to recoil and hide. Keep people out. Don’t attract any attention. Great, but that allows others—including the U.S. Humane Society—to establish the industry’s “image.”

What the industry needs to do is open its doors. Invite the public in. Let “city folks” see what a modern dairy looks like and how they make cows “happy”—or at least healthy and highly productive. How can you tell if a cow is “happy?” Some would like to ascribe human emotions, such as happiness, to cows.

Check out the video about Fair Oaks Farm in Indiana. http://tinyurl.com/FairOaksFarmIndiana This “factory farm” has more than thrown open its doors. It created an educational/information center that has become a tourist attraction.

Rather than hide and hope no one notices you—yeah, right, a big, sometimes smelly dairy on the outskirts of town—California dairy farmers need to pull together to create a center along the line of Fair Oaks’.

Of course, I think that center should be in Bakersfield, where some of the state’s newest and innovative dairies are located, and close to a huge urban center—Southern California.

John Hardisty
Bakersfield, Calif.
http://www.svs2help.com

Posted by John Hardisty on 03/12 at 03:57 PM

Great job in California, David.  While you were away, you missed the March 11th Oprah show, with guest Michael Pollan - “Food Rules”.  Check it out: http://www.oprah.com/showinfo/Food-101-with-Michael-Pollan

I would love to hear what you have to say about it.  I missed almost the entire show, and will have to find some time to look at the web re-run, but I did catch the last couple of minutes, when Mr. Pollan makes the most outrageous statements when Oprah asked about the effects these “new” farming rules will have on struggling nations with starving people, the third world and other areas where they depend on the affordable and healthy food exports from U.S. farmers and ranchers. He basically said “So what?”! “So we have to eat less protein and pay a little more for food, we will all be better off in the long run (sound familiar?). He said, last line before cut to theme music - “‘WE eat an obscene amount of meat.” I didn’t know Michael Pollan was God Himself.  What an arrogant, self-righteous and heartless individual, who has plenty of money to pay three times as much for his organic and artisinal food products.

Posted by Charlotte Allmann on 03/12 at 06:11 PM

Hey I’m so glad I found this article that points this out. I Show dairy cattle at my state fair in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. This year during the meeting with the group i go with we were told that there is a chance we may be harassed by local humane society people, because they’ve just built a new building for themselves. I’m actually kind of scared. Every year at state fair i strive to talk to “city people” about farming and educate them about where their food comes from. I don’t know how I’ll react to someone telling me I’m wrong for training and showing cattle.

Posted by Maighdlin Farrell on 03/13 at 11:06 AM

Good for you, Maighdlin. I have probably talked to you myself (I live less than 2 miles away) . I spend at least two days at the Wisconsin State Fair each year.  One day with the Dog Fair, where we do training demonstrations, Search and Rescue, agility, competition obedience, and so forth, and another day just for fun. We go early and go through every barn. If more uneducated animal lovers, HSUS supporters and vegans went through the barns to see how farming looks these days, they might not be so quick to claim that animal agriculture is cruel. I think anyone would be impressed by the cows on Waterbeds, myself, don’t you?

Posted by Charlotte Allmann on 03/14 at 09:02 PM

I have heard David’s presentation. I have never know anyone who enjoyed his work as much as David does. He tells the truth about the animal rights groups. They are tied together like burmuda grass. All the roots are underground and hard to eradicate. Animal rights is their religion and they are trying to convert the masses to their religion.

Posted by Patricia Van Dam on 03/17 at 01:34 AM

Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.

Add a comment:

Name:

Email: (will not be displayed)

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

« Back to blog homepage