May 04 2011

Three Cups of Animal Scam

Have you heard of Greg Mortenson? Millions of people have read his book, Three Cups of Tea, but his charity—the Central Asia Institute—is getting lots of bad press following an unflattering 60 Minutes investigation.

Mortenson’s claim to fame is his work in Pakistan and Afghanistan, supposedly building schools for poor and disadvantaged children. Mortenson writes that during the early 1990s he got lost while mountain-climbing, and was nursed back to health in a remote village.

60 Minutes, however, cast doubt on many of Mortenson’s claims. Investigators traveled to some of the remote places he wrote about and could find no evidence that the Central Asia Institute had built some of the schools it claimed to. One early Mortenson backer now says Mortenson’s story is a “lie.” (You can find Mortenson’s rebuttals here.)

The shock waves are already resonating throughout the charity world. The attorney general of Montana, where the Central Asia Institute is based, has opened an investigation.

What does this have to do with the Humane Society of the United States? The parallels are startling.

At its core, the 60 Minutes piece is about an eight-figure charity that isn’t doing what its donors expect it to do. The Central Asia Institute has spent $1.5 million promoting its president’s book and paying for a related speaking tour. It’s spending millions more “educating” Americans about the need for action related to its primary purpose—building schools in Asia. Actually building the schools, most donors’ real interest, generally doesn’t make the to-do list.

Sound like anyone we know? The Humane Society of the United States is a nine-figure charity that isn’t doing what most of its donors expect.

A majority of Americans think HSUS gives most of its money—their donations—to pet shelters. But HSUS shares less than 1 percent of its budget with these community-based organizations.

HSUS runs countless “education” campaigns instead of supporting more hands-on work. While HSUS does carry out some hands-on work, such as operating an animal rescue team (sometimes under a cloud of controversy), much of its money funds lobbyists, political campaigns, pension plans, and legal skirmishes.

HSUS CEO Wayne Pacelle is currently on a weeks-long tour to promote his new book, The Bond. It’s a strange title for a book, since Pacelle himself once said in an interview: “I don't have a hands-on fondness for animals. I did not grow up bonded to any particular nonhuman animal. …there's no special bond between me and other animals.”

We’d like to know how much HSUS is spending on its CEO’s book tour, and how much of what must have been a sizable “advance” is going back into his charity. Are the proceeds mostly going into Pacelle’s bank account?

In the 60 Minutes piece about Greg Mortenson, the American Institute of Philanthropy calculates that his Central Asia Institute spends more money domestically “promoting the importance of building schools in Afghanistan and Pakistan than it does actually constructing and funding them overseas.”

That same philanthropy watchdog similarly rates HSUS’s performance, giving the animal rights group a “D” grade overall. It calculates that HSUS spends up to 49 cents to raise a dollar. That’s an embarrassing level of inefficiency.

HSUS deserves a long, hard look based on wasteful financial practices, and its failure to accomplish its donors’ primary goals. After all, if HSUS is correct in arguing that animal deserve legal “rights,” someone has to look out for them.

Posted on 05/04/2011 at 04:17 PM by the HumaneWatch Team

Fundraising & Money • (9) Comments

Share

Comments 

The above told me nothing. I don’t care about
Greg Mortenson. Be more specific regarding Humane Society financial abuses.

Posted by Debbie Edwards on 05/04 at 06:39 PM

The day of reckoning is coming for HSUS and maybe not very far away. It will only take some exposure like the sixty minutes episode you talked about and the dominoes will start to fall. I remember the panic mode hsus got in when wsb TV 2 ran your mini exposé on them. Red alert until the story was quietly snuffed out. That story pointed out the investigation that the Louisiana attorney general had going until he accepted an HSUS donation for a local shelter. They will either die quickly like a tsunami or their overhead will begin to eat them up like a slow cancer. Either way I believe their days are numbered and mostly because of you folks.

Posted by Ken on 05/04 at 07:16 PM

I just got renewal mbrship notice. I WILL NOT BE SENDING MY CHECK FOR HSUS mbrship ever again and you can bet I will be letting EVERYONE I know about this!

Posted by Rhonda kletter on 05/04 at 09:08 PM

not to mention Mr Pacelles many “epiphanies”  when he felt the urge to do his work.. once on school field trip to the zoo.. once on a mountain lake..there are more.. I just cannot remember so many epiphanies .. so little time to make money

Posted by bestuvall on 05/05 at 02:52 AM

Dear Debbie,
This entire site is dedicated to educating and illustrating the financial abuse of H$U$. Whether the blogger is reporting directly on the documents (i.e. tax returns, in-house correspondence, printed quotes, etc) or just drawing parallels, the message is there.

If the blogger has the sense to dig deeper, the visitor should learn to read deeper. Did you not notice all the extra links peppered throughout the article? He’s linking you back to all the ‘specifics.’ I’d say that’s responsible blogging. Check them out!

Posted by Metalhorses on 05/05 at 02:14 PM

Debbie, before you sneer, you might want to go to the documents library and browse around. There you will find decades worth of documenation.

Posted by BADKarma on 05/05 at 02:27 PM

After watching the 60 Minutes program on Greg Mortenson, I immediately e-mailed CBS 60 Minutes to educate them as to the parallels of their story on Greg Mortenson with HSUS.  I also noted the low rating of HSUS with AIP and the fact that AIP’s site indicates that HSUS refused to open their books to them.

Do you think we will hear anything from CBS, even when we put a big scoop in their lap?????

Connie

Posted by Connie on 05/08 at 03:56 PM

Connie not if just a few people write them, but if 10,000 of us do then they will know they have a story and an audience. Wouldn’t that be nice to have h$u$ exposed on national TV? And all the animal rights groups?

Posted by Regan H on 05/10 at 01:15 PM

Bestuvall, I’d like to hear more about Pacelle’s epiphanies.

Posted by Anita on 07/19 at 04:31 PM

Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.

Add a comment:

Name:

Email: (will not be displayed)

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

« Back to blog homepage