Mar 02 2010
What Today’s Polling Numbers Mean
We hope you've had a chance to read through this morning's HumaneWatch press release. It's a great example of the kind of work we are trying to do with this website.
We launched this project just two weeks ago with the goal of showing (not telling) Americans some basic things: that most Americans don't understand what the Humane Society of the United States is really all about, that the organization's money isn't going where the public thinks it's going, and that a lot more transparency will be required if the organization is going to earn a legitimate place in our national discussion about animals.
Again, the key word is show, not tell.
We could stand on a soap box and shout that most of your friends and neighbors wrongly believe HSUS is an umbrella group for pet shelters. We could go on national television and complain that most of HSUS's donors think the majority of their contributions are being sent to pet shelters (which is not the case—not by a long shot). And we could do dozens of radio interviews, claiming that many donations to HSUS have the effect of robbing money from needy pet shelters because the contributors think their local "humane societies" are getting a huge cut of the action.
And you'd be absolutely right to be skeptical. Until now.
Just to be clear, a nationally recognize polling firm (Opinion Research Corporation, the same guys CNN works with) did this work for us. They polled 1,008 Americans for us last week, and then their number-crunching wizards adjusted the results to arrive at a sample of 1,000 Americans that reflected a statistically accurate sample.
Here are the highlights, including a few nuggets you won't find in the press release.
- 79 percent of Americans say they are "very" or "somewhat" familiar with HSUS;
- 77 percent say they have a "very" or "somewhat" favorable view of HSUS;
- 63 percent believe that if they had $100 to donate to charity, HSUS "would be a worthy recipient of that money."
(Interesting side note: Only 31 percent said they have a "very" or "somewhat" favorable view of another animal rights group, the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine. And the "net favorable" numbers for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals are hovering at just 49 percent. That's about twice the public esteem as we associate with the U.S. Congress. Which isn't saying much.)
But all of this is just a baseline. When the pollsters asked true/false questions, the data got really interesting:
-
71 percent answered TRUE to this question:"The Humane Society of the United States is an umbrella group that represents thousands of local humane societies all across America."
(That's actually false. HSUS doesn't "represent" a single one.)
-
63 percent answered TRUE to this question:"My local humane society or pet shelter is AFFILIATED with the Humane Society of the United States."
(That's false too, by definition. HSUS is not affiliated with any U.S. pet shelters or humane societies.)
-
59 percent answered TRUE to this question:"The Humane Society of the United States contributes most of its money to local organizations that care for dogs and cats."
(False again, unless one-half of one percent suddenly counts as "most.")
... and so on. We think you get the idea.
So from here on in, let's not entertain the ridiculous notion that most Americans who give money to HSUS know exactly what they're doing, agree with the organization's agenda, and don't expect their contributions to filter down to the local level.
Again, showing, not telling.
Please share these numbers far and wide. HumaneWatch is just getting warmed up.
Posted on 03/02/2010 at 09:27 AM by the HumaneWatch Team
The Best of HumaneWatch • Fundraising & Money • Pets • (6) CommentsComments
Dogman,
Read further back on this site or go to the Document Library here and you’ll find the HSUS tax documents from 2008. David has some of the info broken down from there.
Well, if you would like to donate to a tax deductible 501c3 place that will use all the money in a frugal way, go to http://www.wvhumanesociety.com The West Volusia Humane Society in Deland Florida. They are a no kill facility established in 1955. It is very old in design.
They didn’t have me fooled…I am just glad someone is starting to expose the HSUS for what they really are…a bunch of lobbyists using other peoples money to fund all their Anti campaigns!
i shared your info on HSUS site here on fb last week, and of course they removed my comments, stating they were “misleading.” I also stopped my direct pay to the HSUS. I have taken that monthly amount and added it to the monthly amount I give our local shelter. It’s not much, but I know I’m doing my part to help. We also started walking the dogs at the shelter last week. I have a little girl in mind, to bring home so my Sammie has a playmate
. Thank you so much for keeping us informed. btw, I hate to ask,,but I also have a monthly contribution to the ASPCA. I hope their credentials are much more “honorable” than HSUS???? Sincerely, Kimberly W, Sherburn, MN
I’m shocked !! I have been making donations to HSUS for years and I never dreamed that my money would be going anywhere besides my local shelters. I am changing all that by donating DIRECTLY to the shelter. I don’t care about the tax deduction, I just want to help the animals. BTW-Don’t forget about PETA—they might be a little radical, but they do good work. I am actively involved with them-not with money, but with my time.
Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.
Add a comment:
After reading this article, I couldn’t believe it. Most people like me would have thought that a good amount of the donations would have went to help our buddies. I would like to know where all the funds go and why are local animal shelters are not being helped out in times like these.