Even if Jimmy Carter was president the last time you made a contribution to the Humane Society of the United States, you may be surprised to learn that the animal rights group probably counts you among its vaunted “11 million members and constituents.”
Most organizations measure actual membership the way a health club or college alumni association would do it: If you’ve paid dues or donated money in the past 12 months, you’re a “member.” By that math, HSUS’s total membership number is barely 450,000.
But the animal rights group has a few creative accounting methods that inflate these numbers—by as much as 2,400 percent! This can be helpful when Wayne Pacelle, Mike Markarian, or other HSUS lobbyists try to persuade lawmakers to do their bidding. (More members translates to more "clout," even if it's manufactured with weasel words.)
Here’s a quick guide to HSUS “constituency” jargon and how the group hides how few Americans it actually represents.
We’ve published several articles to date about how HSUS artificially boosts its membership figures:
- February 2010: HSUS’s 2008 federal tax return showed that it only printed 420,000 copies of each issue of its “membership” magazine.
- July 2010: In a fundraising letter, HSUS CEO Wayne Pacelle writes that HSUS has “1,200,000” members, not 11 million.
- July 2010: Humane Society International, which survives largely on grants from HSUS, fictitiously claims to have “11 million supporters globally.”
- October 2010: An HSUS spokesperson tells a Missouri newspaper that the organization “has 300,000 members in the United States.” This is later edited online (with no notice of a correction) to reflect a ridiculous claim: that HSUS “has 300,000 members in the state.”
- October 2010: HSUS’s 2009 tax return shows that its membership magazine went to “more than 450,000” people.
- November 2010: HSUS’s Paul Shapiro claims (presumably with fingers crossed) that HSUS’s “11 million supporters across the U.S. … are supporters that donate to the organization.”
- December 2010: Wayne Pacelle claims in a radio interview that his organization has “11 million members and active supporters”
We need a real HSUS expert to make sense of this and separate truth from fiction, right? Thankfully, HSUS has one on staff and he’s pretty open about what’s real and what’s not.
Geoff Handy is HSUS’s Vice President of Media and Online Communications. He’s a fundraising wizard, to put it mildly, which is why The Resource Alliance (a UK-based organization for professional fundraisers) invited him to deliver a keynote speech during its 2010 online Virtual Expo.
Here’s how Handy was billed on the program (emphasis added):
Beyond the myth of integrated fundraising: how we combine email, social media and telephones with our 1.3 million supporters
Handy’s "1.3 million" figure is a lot closer to Pacelle’s “1,200,000” number than to any of HSUS’s other propaganda. And he’s in a position to see the real numbers staring back at him from his laptop every morning.
Presuming Handy is right, what the heck is a “supporter” anyway? If HSUS had 1.3 million “members”—people who contribute annually—he would just say so.
We recently took note of a Chronicle of Philanthropy article (not available online, sadly) from 2007 in which a reporter described HSUS “supporters” as “people who have made at least one donation in the past three years.” If that’s HSUS’s working definition, the whole picture begins to make more sense.
Here’s what we think all the seemingly interchangeable membership vocabulary actually means:
- An HSUS member is someone who gave money in the most recent fiscal year. HSUS’s most recent tax return, which was signed under penalty of perjury, shows that there were about 450,000 of these in 2009.
- An HSUS supporter is someone who gave some money during the last three fiscal years. HSUS VP Geoff Handy says there are about 1.3 million of those. That probably means there’s a “base” of about 350,000 people who contribute enough annually ($25) to get the magazine, plus a larger group of people who are one-time or occasional donors of somewhere around $5 or $10. Perhaps they see one of HSUS’s many misleading ads and think this money goes to their local pet shelters.
- An HSUS constituent is anyone who has ever made a cash donation, signed an online petition, or interacted with the HSUS universe in any way that would add him or her to a mailing list. HSUS claims to have 11 million of these. We presume they’re all actually still alive, although it’s hard to imagine that HSUS has the means to completely scrub the deceased from its lists.
We’re left to wonder what the public would think if the National Association of Realtors claimed to have 180 million “members and constituents,” including everyone who’s ever used a realtor to buy or sell a home. Or if the National Education Association (a teachers union) used similar “constituent” language to suggest that it represents everyone in America who ever went to school.
Sound shady? Most Americans would heap scorn on anyone engaging in such shameless self-aggrandizement.
Ideally, Wayne Pacelle should just come clean and start promoting HSUS with a real, honest, and auditable total of the Americans his group actually represents on a year-to-year basis. Anything less is plainly dishonest.
But HSUS is already willing to divert 50 percent of the public’s contributions into more fundraising, and another 49 percent into something other than the pet shelters its donors think they’re supporting. Somehow, we’re not holding our breath on this one.